Mascot Madness: Mascot vs Mascot First Round

College Basketball, Sam Wicks

It’s likely that March Madness got its name not from the unpredictability and the regular upsets, but the pure insanity that we are all driven to as year after year we watch our innocent, clean, hopeful brackets break down after a day and half. So while we’re all torn between rooting for an underdog upsetting a favorite (see Middle Tennessee) and loathing an underdog for upsetting a favorite and upending our brackets (see Middle Tennessee), we can take solace in the other tournament taking place at this time: Mascot Madness.


Be sure to let your opinions be known in the comments and check back tomorrow for the next round of Mascot Madness!



(1) Kansas Jayhawk vs. (16) Austin Peay Governors

The Governors take their nickname from the university’s namesake while the Jayhawks were an abolitionist group in the 1800s. Lack of originality would normally win over a bloody past, but with the rough political landscape we’re currently going through and a logo that looks more like a tough oil baron than a supportive politician, the Jayhawks win this one.

Winner: Kansas Jayhawks

Kansas Jayhawks







(8) Colorado State Rams vs. (9) UConn Huskies

Anyone can request Jonathan the Husky to show up at an event which is a big plus. But CAM the Ram has a name made entirely of capital letters. Good luck finding that anywhere else.

Winner: Colorado State

Colorado State








(5) Maryland Terrapins vs. (12) South Dakota State Jackrabbits

In an ironic twist on the beloved fable, the lower seeded jackrabbits have a chance to take out the confident terrapins. This time, hare beats tortoise.

Winner: South Dakota State Jackrabbits

South Dakota State Jackrabbits








(4) California Golden Bears vs. (13) Hawaii Rainbow Warriors

Vili the Warrior was as fierce as they come, and he’s a family man too, leaving the University of Hawaii to spend more time with his kids. Without a true mascot Hawaii would lose to almost anyone in the first round…except Oski the bear. He looks friendly…but that’s about all he has going for him.

Winner: Hawaii Rainbow Warriors

Hawaii Rainbow Warriors








(6) Arizona Wildcats vs. (11) Wichita State Shockers

WuShock is full of history and a reminder of the athletic program’s humble beginnings. According to science, wildcats are naturally carnivores and do not eat grains. Victory to the Shockers.

Winner: Wichita State Shocker

Wichita State Shocker








(3) Miami Hurricanes vs. (14) Buffalo Bulls

Considering inflation, the 1926 Miami Hurricane caused roughly $1.5 billion in damage, which is roughly $1.5 billion more than any mascot should.

Winner: Buffalo Bulls

Buffalo Bulls








(7) Iowa Hawkeyes vs. (10) Temple Owls

A classic battle of the birds, Iowa is able to overcome its lack of superhero marketing by using the name Herky, but that can’t beat Stella the Owl and her part time gig as a teacher at the zoo.

Winner: Temple Owls

Temple Owls







(2) Villanova Wildcats vs. (15) UNC Asheville Bulldogs

Villanova is unfortunately on the losing end of sharing the same mascot as another team in the region. And on the losing end of a bulldog that has multiple heads to change his mood. An early upset.

Winner: UNC Asheville Bulldogs

UNC Asheville Bulldogs











(1) Oregon Ducks vs. (16) Holy Cross Crusaders

The Duck has just about everything you’re looking for in a mascot: lovable appearance, an agreeable yet controversial deal with Disney, a healthy physique from countless pushups, and a suspension for fighting a cougar. But there’s one thing it’s missing: a name. And that’s where Ignatius T. “Iggy” Crusader is able to pull off the upset.

Winner: Holy Cross Crusaders

Holy Cross Crusaders








(8) Saint Joseph’s Hawks vs. (9) Cincinnati Bearcats

One needs an explanation and one never stops flapping its wings. There’s a reason the Hawk is one of the most decorated mascots in the league.

Winner: Saint Joseph’s Hawks

Saint Josephs Hawks







(5) Baylor Bears vs. (12) Yale Bulldogs

In what may be the most unexciting matchup in the competition, bears and bulldogs are two all too common mascot choices around the country. When in doubt, go with the one that would win in a normal fight: bears take this one on a technicality.

Winner: Baylor Bears

Baylor Bears








(4) Duke Blue Devils vs. (13) UNC Wilmington Seahawks

It’s tough to pick against a mascot that shares your name, but Sammy the Seahawk can’t stand up to the history behind the Blue Devil. Though it was met with resistance and took a few failed tries to catch on, it’s a call back to soldiers, World War I and an allied victory.

Winner: Duke Blue Devils

Duke Blue Devils








(6) Texas Longhorns vs. (11) Northern Illinois Panthers

Not only are there no other longhorns across the US, but Bevo has also attended a presidential inauguration and had a five hour long Christmas special on the Longhorn Network.

Winner: Texas Longhorns









(3) Texas A&M Aggies (14) Green Bay Phoenix

While the phoenix is unique and a powerful mythical creature, it’s tough to give support to Phlash when it spells its name wrong for alliteration’s sake. Ultimately, that’s irrelevant since Reveille IX, the Border collie representing A&M, is the highest ranking member of the school’s corps of cadets.

Winner: Texas A&M Aggies

Texas A&M Aggies








(7) Oregon State Beavers vs. (10) VCU Rams

Rodney the Ram is a mascot of the people. Over 1,200 surveys were collected to give Rodney his new look in 2010, proving his ability to listen to what his constituency wants. His resume is listed on his website for a quick look at his past accomplishments. And that’s enough to beat Benny’s past as a bronze statue come to life.

Winner: VCU Rams

VCU Rams









(2) Oklahoma Sooners vs. (15) Cal State Bakersfield Roadrunner

Is roadrunner singular or plural? Don’t bother checking the school’s website because it’ll confuse you even more. The Sooners win by default.

Winner: Oklahoma Sooner

Oklahoma Sooners









(1) North Carolina Tar heels vs. (16) Florida Gulf Coast Eagles

As their number one seed implies, North Carolina has the weapons to run all over you. And Rameses is no different, appearing not in one, not two, but in three forms at UNC sporting events. It’s a triple threat that’s simply too much to handle.

Winner: North Carolina Tar Heels

North Carolina Tar heels








(8) USC Trojans vs. (9) Providence Friars

USC is another recipient of an all too easy first round matchup. Is he smiling? Is he remembering past sins? The face of the Friar is too terrifying to understand.

Winner: USC Trojans

USC Trojans








(5) Indiana Hoosiers vs. (12) Chattanooga Mocs

Another 5 vs. 12 seed that’s too close to call. The Hoosiers bring a punch by having a number of past mascot representations, (a Collie, an old guy, a bulldog, and a bison), but the Mocs counter with a history of their own featuring a water moccasin, a moccasin shoe, and a mockingbird. After this long battle, the Mocs come out on top by at least having a mascot today.

Winner: Chattanooga Mocs

Chattanooga Mocs








(4) Kentucky Wildcats vs. (13) Stonybrook Seawolves

An updated take on the age old cat vs. dog rivalry, only this time, one species is a mythical sea creature.

Winner: Stonybrook Seawolves

Stonybrook Seawolves








(6) Notre Dame Fighting Irish vs. (11) Michigan Wolverines

Notre Dame fans might think they have this one locked up: the leprechaun is real, he dances, he jigs, and wild wolverines aren’t even native to Michigan. They don’t even use a real animal! But when you remember that live wolverines had to stop being used because they were too ferocious, it’s clear that Michigan is as tough as they come.

Winner: Michigan Wolverines

Michigan Wolverines








(3) West Virginia Mountaineers vs. (14) Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks

If only schools could tie! Here we have two universities represented by genuine, bearded men. They’re tough, they’re manly, and they openly wield weapons. The Lumberjacks may have an axe with a face on it, but the Mountaineer gets a tailored costume every year, and that’s a level of class that’s difficult to find.

Winner: West Virginia Mountaineers










(7) Wisconsin Badgers vs. (10) Pittsburgh Panthers

ROC the panther has a stellar resume. Another all-capital-letter name and possibly the first panther mascot in the country, ROC is fierce, formidable, and alliterative. Bucky Badger however, is tried and true, having survived scandal and political threats from politicians. Like Howard Koop’s failed attempts in the 70s, ROC comes up short.

Winner: Wisconsin Badger

Wisconsin Badgers











(2) Xavier Musketeers vs. (15)Webster State Wildcats

The Xavier Musketeer has a sidekick simply named the Blue Blob.

Winner: Xavier Musketeers

Xavier Musketeers











(1) Virginia Cavaliers vs. (16) Hampton Pirates

Wahoo! It’s an unofficial name, but it’s officially a top rallying cry. He’s got a horse, he’s got a sword, and he’s got our hearts.

Winner: Virginia Cavaliers

Virgina Cavaliers










(8) Texas Tech Red Raiders vs. (9)Butler Bulldogs

Anytime your school has two mascots, you have an advantage over your opponent. Anytime one of those mascots is a member of an organization called the Saddle Tramps, you have a win.

Winner: Texas Tech Red Raiders

Texas Tech Red Raiders








(5) Purdue Boilermakers vs. (12) Little Rock Trojans

Just in case you needed extra clarification of this nickname, Purdue’s mascot is the Boilermaker Special. There have been 7 and it’s a train.

Winner: Purdue Boilermakers

Purdue Boilermakers










(4) Iowa State Cyclones vs. (13) Iona Gaels

A cardinal is used to represent Iowa State University because of the school’s colors: cardinal and gold; and because the school decided a cyclone would be too difficult to make into a costume. Maybe they’re right, but that negative attitude won’t help them in round one.

Winner: Iona Gaels

Iona Gaels











(6) Seton Hall Pirates vs. (11) Gonzaga Bulldogs

A dog named Spike? A student named Captain Zag? Normally two lockdown qualities, unless you’re up against a team that’s called the Pirates because they literally stole victory away from another team. That’s an origin story that’s hard to compete with.

Winner: Seton Hall Pirates

Seton Hall Pirates










(3) Utah Utes vs. (14) Fresno State Bulldogs

Utah uses a red-tailed hawk as their mascot, a bird indigenous to the state. The Ute people are a tribe native to Utah and the state is named after them. Utah pride runs deep with this team.

Winner: Utah Utes










(7) Dayton Flyers vs. (10) Syracuse Orange

This is a unique matchup: a barnstormer in Rudy Flyer and an orange in Otto. The individuality of both mascots would be enough to beat many teams in the first round. When picking the orange as the mascot, the University’s Chancellor put together an 18-member committee who elected a wolf. The Chancellor then ignored that recommendation after a successful campaign from the students who acted as the Orange. That’s dedication.

Winner: Syracuse Orange

Syracuse Orange








(2) Michigan State Spartans vs. (15) Middle Tennessee Blue Raiders

Sparty is 7 feet tall and weighs 30 pounds, presumably with 0% body fat. His abs show through his armor. His knee caps blend seamlessly with his thigh muscles. He was born to win.

Winner: Michigan State Spartans

Michigan State Spartans












Sam Wicks

Sam Wicks is a Fordham University graduate and a consistently average fantasy football enthusiast. He was born in Seattle, raised in Boston, and currently lives in New York where his team loyalty is varied, but no less fierce. He loves all things football and track and field related. Outside of sports, Sam is a big fan of plants, dinosaurs, and scuba diving.



Back to Top